Ebook Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press
How a suggestion can be obtained? By looking at the celebrities? By going to the sea as well as considering the sea weaves? Or by reading a book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press Everybody will certainly have particular characteristic to get the inspiration. For you who are dying of books and still get the inspirations from books, it is truly terrific to be here. We will certainly show you hundreds compilations of the book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press to review. If you similar to this Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press, you could additionally take it as your own.
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press
Ebook Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press
Make use of the innovative innovation that human establishes this day to find guide Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press conveniently. But initially, we will ask you, how much do you love to review a book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press Does it consistently up until surface? For what does that book read? Well, if you really love reading, try to read the Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press as one of your reading compilation. If you just read the book based on demand at the time and unfinished, you should try to like reading Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press first.
Checking out book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press, nowadays, will not force you to constantly acquire in the shop off-line. There is an excellent place to acquire guide Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press by on the internet. This internet site is the best website with lots numbers of book collections. As this Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press will certainly remain in this book, all books that you need will correct here, as well. Simply search for the name or title of the book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press You can locate just what you are searching for.
So, even you require responsibility from the company, you may not be puzzled anymore considering that publications Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press will always aid you. If this Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press is your best partner today to cover your job or work, you can when feasible get this publication. Exactly how? As we have informed previously, simply check out the web link that our company offer here. The conclusion is not just the book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press that you look for; it is just how you will get several publications to support your ability as well as capability to have piece de resistance.
We will certainly show you the best as well as best way to get book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press in this globe. Great deals of collections that will certainly support your responsibility will be below. It will certainly make you feel so perfect to be part of this web site. Becoming the participant to consistently see just what up-to-date from this book Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press website will certainly make you feel ideal to search for the books. So, recently, and here, get this Views Into The Chinese Room: New Essays On Searle And Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press to download and install and also save it for your precious worthy.
The most famous challenge to computational cognitive science and artificial intelligence is the philosopher John Searle's "Chinese Room" argument. Searle argued that, although machines can be devised to respond to input with the same output as would a mind, machines--unlike minds--lack understanding of the symbols they process. 19 essays by leading scientists and philosophers assess, renew, and respond to this crucial challenge.
- Sales Rank: #1488559 in Books
- Published on: 2002-09-26
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 6.10" h x .80" w x 9.20" l, 1.40 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 426 pages
Review
Searle fans will not be disappointed ... The editors have produced a genuinely interdisciplinary volume, which should stand for some time as the book to read on the Chinese room argument. John Preston has also written an excellent introduction, so newcomers to the debate will find themselves well prepared for the essays which follow. The Philosophers' Magazine Produced to mark the 21st birthday of the Chinese Room and bears witness to the argument's continuing fascination ... kicks off with an excellent introduction ... This is an excellent gathering of scholars. Times Higher Education Supplement
About the Author
John Preston is Senior Lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Reading. Mark Bishop is Lecturer in Cybernetics at the University of Reading.
Most helpful customer reviews
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful.
Ignore the previous comments on "trick philosophy"
By R.U.R.
The Chinese Room Argument (CRA) has nothing to do with the speed of computers or any future developments in artifical intelligence (at least as understood as following from Turing). The CRA is a purely formal argument intended to refute the claim that computers (defined as Turing machines) can think, or can understand, or are minds solely by virtue of their formal description. (This claim is the essence of "computationalism," after Turing's original formulation.) The CRA is that: 1) Syntax is not semantics. 2) The implemented synatactical or formal program of a computer is not sufficient to generate semantics. 3) Minds have semantics. 4) Therefore, computers (so defined) are not minds/cannot think/do not understand because they are not sufficient to generate semantics.
For example, the concepts we employ to think and the words we use to speak have meanings. But there is nothing in computationalism as syntax that has any meaning whatsoever. Whatever meaning an implemented formal program has results from its being programmed or interpreted by us. Syntax (e.g., a computer program) has no causal powers. Whatever causal powers computers have (e.g., to fly airplanes) results from our programming and our assigning interpretations to the electrical charge insides a chip, not from the program in itself.
The chapters in Views Into the Chinese Room attack different aspects of the CRA. But they address it as an argument that stands or falls on the truth of the premises and the validity of the inference, not on engineering questions such as the speed of computers, which are irrelevant. Searle believes that there are, in fact, thinking machines -- we human beings are biological machines that think. And he believes that there also could be artificially made machines that think. The CRA is meant to show only that an implemented computer program by itself cannot generate mental content or semantic content.
For a clear explanation of the CRA, see chapter 15 of this book, by Stevan Harnad, the editor of The Behavioral and Brain Sciences, where Searle's original paper appeared twenty years ago. Do not rely on reviewers who do not understand the argument in the first place.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Five Stars
By Chris H
Great collection
0 of 3 people found the following review helpful.
The Chinese Room Syndrome
By Tojagi
This book isn't as much about 'how computers think' as it is about how computer scientists think - and feel.
On page 52 John Searle states that CRA (Chinese Room Argument) rests on two "fundamental logical truths":
1.) Syntax is not semantics (An English speaker could learn to recite passages from the Koran in Arabic yet have no understanding of their meaning.)
2.) Simulation is not duplication (A computer program could simulate digestion but that doesn't mean it could digest a pizza and beer.)
That's it! It just doesn't seem like rocket science to me. And I've never seen such a battle of straw men. Straw man 1: the Turing test proves human consciousness; straw man 2: CRA proves that machines can't think; straw man 3: computation is not part of our cognitive process - and so on. Professor Searle said in a lecture that it took him five minutes to develop this little thought experiment. So what's all the fuss about? I think I found the answer on page 295:
"One of the charges that had been laid against Searle by his critics had been that his wrong-headed critique had squelched funding for Artificial Intelligence..." - Stevan Harnad (p295)
I have no idea what goes on in academia with research funding and all. But I have a sneaking suspicion that this is the source of much of the hyperbole about `thinking machines'.
Terry Winograd, computer scientist at Stanford, uses the postmodern technique to counter Searle's argument. The meaning of the word `understand', he claims, is a social construction. Therefore it is erroneous to believe that there is a right or wrong answer to the question: does the computer `understand' the language it is using?
"The error is not one of flawed logic in the argument about artificial intelligence, but is more fundamental and more pervasive. It has to do with the basic orientation we take towards the truth or falsity of statements in natural language." - Terry Winograd (p80)
On page 94 one of the editors of this book, John Preston, questions Winograd:
JP: "You say that all uses of the term `understand' and its cognates depend on certain concerns and perspectives. Isn't there a problem of self-reflexion here? Mustn't it be that your own uses of those terms are right only for certain concerns and from certain perspectives, but wrong for and from others?"
TW: "You correctly point out that if I am to be consistent in being relativistic, then I must apply it to my own statements as well as to the ones I am analyzing. Indeed, my own evaluations of attitudes are matters of social construction that is not the same as individual subjective opinion, but is grounded in the social discourse rather than in an appeal to objective truth." - Terry Winograd (p94)
What I see here is a person operating at the very, very highest level of academia resorting to the typical California postmodern response, `It's all relative man.' It's comical. Like a father saying, `Don't you try to tell me my baby doesn't understand English.'
Nevertheless, this book explores one of the most fascinating philosophical questions of our time: will we someday be able to build machines like ourselves that will replicate human consciousness? Considering the enormity of that question, it is no wonder the overwhelming response to Searle's CRA has sometimes taken on the character of religious passion.
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press PDF
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press EPub
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press Doc
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press iBooks
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press rtf
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press Mobipocket
Views into the Chinese Room: New Essays on Searle and Artificial IntelligenceFrom Clarendon Press Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar